Cognitive sciences and psychoanalysis
Antonio Imbasciati
Virtuality in the Psychoanalytic Method
Luiz Carlos Uchôa Junqueira Filho
On truth, desire and virtuality. Relations
with virtual objects Ruggero Levy
Psychoanalysis and the new trends of human
experience determined by globalization Alirio Dantas Jr.
And so? With or without pain?
Miguel Calmon du Pin e Almeida
A psychoanalysis session and other day-dreams
Maria Helena Souza Fontes
Considerations on a late Oedipus Complex
on women. The eldest daughter and the elderly
father. The widow mother. The single mother
Maria P. Manhães
Antigone's saga
Wagner Vidille
Subordinate Analysis
Luiz Meyer
On training analysis
Eustachio Portella Nunes
Cognitive sciences and psychoanalysis
Antonio Imbasciati, Milão
The author confronts the inner
experience as it is described by psychoanalysis with
the experience that cognitive science describes as
informations processing. He arguments that the same
events are described from two different vertices and
that the two descriptions may be translated one in
the other. We need to find out what are the internal
informations that are processed in the unconscious
affective experience which happens in relations. This
may be possible if we can formulate a general theory
about mind operating, which may consider psychoanalytic
observations from a mnestic and communicational view
point. The author underlines some difficulties owed
to Freud's meta-psychology in the theorical tradition
of psychoanalysis. Energetic and instinctual theory
had an explicative purpose, beyond its clinic descriptive
one, which tuned psychoanalysis with other contemporary
sciences. That explicative value is not yet valid
and postfreudian theories seem to disregard the "explication"
aim. A theoretical void has secluded psychoanalysis
from nowadays sciences of mind. The author considers
how objectual theories may be developed and transformed
to explore experience as learning, mnesic pathway,
memory processing, and he proposes a "psychoanalytic
cognitivism", by a personal explicative theory
about mind development.
Virtuality in the Psychoanalytic Method.
Luiz Carlos Uchôa Junqueira Filho,
São Paulo
We are facing growing questioning
nowadays concerning the efficacy of the psychoanalytic
method in promoting a real humanization, in a social
and cultural background progressively involved in
the webs of virtual reality and globalization.
Nevertheless, if we carefully observe psychoanalytical
development, we can see that virtuality has always
been present in its course, as an intrinsic element
to thought processes, or as an operational tool in
the "transference neurosis". As a matter
of fact, the reenactment of infantile conflicts in
the transference scenery, that is, its repetition
as Freud said, or its actualization, as we would say
today, constitutes the central paradox of our method,
something at the same time real and illusory.
And what affords that paradox? In my opinion, what
we could call a "play spirit", acknowledged
by Winnicott when he understands psychoanalysis as
a highly developed form of play. So, it's necessary
to deeply comprehend this "play factor",
what I tried to do through Johan Huizinga's ideas,
expounded in his wonderful essay "Homo Ludens
- Play as a cultural element".
Trying to better understand our paradox, from an epistemological
point of view, I introduce Deleuze's ideas concerning
the actual and the virtual, and also Pierre Levy's
concepts about virtual reality and collective intelligence.
Finally, understanding that psychoanalytical method
is essentially framed to help the promotion of an
actual and virtual humanization, I sketch a possible
insertion of psychoanalysis in the Virtual Era.
On truth, desire and virtuality. Relations
with virtual objects
Ruggero Levy, Porto Alegre
The author starts the paper by
commenting the question of truth in psychoanalysis,
such as an epistemologic construction that aims the
apprehension of the psychic reality of the subject,
as well as to the feeling of being genuine, to exist
as a subject with self desire. He understands from
Bion and Winnicott contributions that the apprehension
of psychic reality, as well as the genuineness of
the sentiment of being, are built on intersubjectivity.
The other, as object, has a fundamental structure
role. It is studied how through the new technologic,
especially virtuality, can interfere in this process,
by affecting the feeling of being genuine and alienating
the subject from his own desire. Thus a study is done
on what is a virtual object, its characteristics and
to which type of object relationship he refers.
Psychoanalysis and the new trends of human
experience determined by globalization.
Alirio Dantas Jr., Recife
The author seeks to reflect on
some of the consequences that the globalization process
might bring to the contemporary man and for psychoanalysis.
Considering the higher frequency and the range of
pathological phenomena determined by psychical suffering,
the author critically questions the results of such
changes for mankind. Supported by the concept of the
" ego ideal ", the paper tries to underline
the narcissistic nature of modern times, once defined
as "the culture of narcissism" or as "the
image era". It stresses that this "project"
has the purpose of overcoming the "castration
anxiety" and of defensively replacing the limitations
imposed by the frustrating nature of human experience.
The author emphasizes that these defence mechanisms
are already a part of the knowledge brought by psychoanalysis
to the understanding of the human singularities. On
the theoretical level they do not represent a new
challenge. He points out that psychoanalysts are familiar
with the use of regression to the narcissistic economy
and omnipotence as attempted alternatives to the "castration
anxiety". Finally, he emphasizes that any human
project supported by such regressions can only lead
to failure, causing enormous suffering and a strong
tendency to sickness, both psychically and physically.
And so? With or without pain?
Miguel Calmon du Pin e Almeida, Rio
de Janeiro
The author discusses resistances
to psychoanalysis. At the outset, the resistances
originates from the contemporaneity, and, later, the
way that psychoanalysis resists to itself.
The author doesn't believe that the demand for new
concepts is a distinctive trait of our days, and outlines
the risks of the exigency for efficacy and immediate
results for the application of the psychoanalytic
method; he studies the conception of pain as deviation;
and concludes the presentation with a brief reflection
about the psychoanalytic clinic, taking the paradox
as the most suitable of this discourse.
A psychoanalysis session and other day-dreams
Maria Helena Souza Fontes, São
Paulo
The writing of this work is presented,
as a psychoanalysis session, including the authors'
free associations and reveries. These day-dreams and
free associations derive from the clinical facts of
a session and from a Bion's theoric statement.
The emerging elements refer to pleasure, memory and
to the feeling of loneliness.
Considerations on a late Oedipus Complex on
women. The eldest daughter and the elderly father. The
widow mother. The single mother.
Maria P. Manhães, Rio de Janeiro
Based upon the treatment of two
elderly male patients, the late Oedipus complex is
discussed, primarily bringing into the fore the role
of daughters who have not fully overcome the Oedipus
stage.
In respect to single or widow mothers, this paper
aims to focus the neurotic relationship that a woman
might have with her male child. The behavior they
develop in relation to their male children might occur
due to incestuous fantasies, which are common to all
human beings.
The author attempts to clarify this situation through
the study of incest, mythology and history.
Antigone's saga
Wagner Vidille, São Paulo
Using as reference two texts
by Sophocles, Antigone and Oedipus at Colonus, the
author examines the probable unconscious motivations
of the mythical character Antigone in the choice of
her own death. The heroine, condemned by a decree
of the tyrant Creon to confinement in a cave where
she would die by asphyxia, anticipates her own death
committing suicide by hanging herself.
To grasp the character, the author thinks it is necessary
to understand the social matrix from which the heroine
emerges, the rules of burial ideology in Athens in
the 5th century B., the atmosphere that surrounded
dramatic representations and the functions of the
drama related to the political constitution of 'pólis'.
Considering the paradigm of death of the female in
the Greek tragedy: the sacrifice of the virgins and
the suicide of the wives, the author understands the
events that precede Antigone's suicide and the suicidal
act itself as a group of actions that allow her to
create a kind of death outside the norms. The heroine,
through the use of a 'thanatic zone' different from
that used by the virgins, the nape (aukhén)
instead of the throat (dére), assures her progression
towards a more developed feminine attitude, fantastically
acquiring the peculiar status of the wives. Breaking
the tragic norm by which the virgins do not kill themselves
but are killed, she assumes the authorship of her
destiny, incriminates Creon as the executioner of
her condemnation and gratifies the urges of her incestuous
longing, finding, post-mortem, the renegade femininity
and sexual maturity.
Subordinate Analysis
Luiz Meyer, São Paulo
"Should training analysis
be maintained?" This question, made by Elias
Rocha Barros, the chair of IPA Training Congress of
2001 is used by the author as a point of departure
to expose his ideas on the subject.
The paper is composed of three parts. In the first
one a survey is made of the most important critiques
on training analysis; in the second part the structural
functioning of training analysis is studied; and in
the third part, the author presents two hypotheses
trying to explain why training analysis is still maintained.
Training analysis is then described as a fetiche and
an ideological formation. As a fetiche it is used
by analysts to refuse the limitations of analysis
tout-court; and as an ideological formation it functions
as a means to hide its symptomatic character making
it look "natural" through the functioning
of institutional prescriptions.
The author thus says no to the initial question and
he even proposes that any and all differentiated form
of analysis should be banished and that responsibility
for the analysis shoud be left to those who are analyzed.
This would be an initial measure in helping to eliminate
the ideological mode of functioning of the Institution.
On training analysis
Eustachio Portella Nunes, Rio de Janeiro
The author intends to demonstrate
that the role of the didactic analyst has been harmful
to psychoanalytic societies. This is not due to inadequacy
or incompetence. In general didactic analysts are
chosen among the best in each society. There is, however,
an intrinsic contradiction between the role of the
psychoanalyst and the work of a didactic analyst who,
as the term itself implies, must teach. The analyst,
as analyst, can be neither teacher nor judge. His
aim is to let the patient express himself, as freely
as possible, on all his affectionate and aggressive
aspects without needing to please a teacher who is
judging him. Therefore, it is important for the one
being analyzed to be able to disagree with the analyst
on all theoretical and practical aspects of life.
A successful analysis is the one in which the one
being analyzed feels free to be what he is knowing
that the analyst allows him the freedom to be so.
The analyst who communicates his doctrinal concepts
to the ones he analyses has stopped being an analyst
to become a teacher. This is the role of the professors
in charge of theoretical courses and of the supervisors
who guide the student's clinical work, but even then
the student should be respected and allowed to hold
opinions different from those of his instructors.
As there is no square triangle there should be no
didactic analyst.
Rua Sergipe,
475 - 8º s/ 807 - São Paulo - SP - Brazil
Phone: (11) 3661-8709 Fax: (11) 3661-9473
E-mail: correio@rbp.org.br