The autistic states and the theory of transformations.
The autistic transformations: a proposition
Célia Fix Korbivcher
Institutional romance
Carlos Ferreira Lopes Pires Leal
Directing the scene: the analytical pair
on the stage of emotions
Gina Khafif Levinzon
Ars Longa Vita Brevis
Ester Hadassa Sandler e Ligia Todescan Lessa Mattos
Adolescents without limits or "limit-functioning"
faced with an exigency soliciting the "dismissal
of the subject"?
Mônica Guimarães Teixeira do Amaral
Sexuality and creativity: some considerations,
with emphasis on masculinity
José Nepomuceno
Beyond transference: second thoughts concerning
the capacity to hallucinate
Claudio Castelo Filho
The said and the unsaid - Secret structures
and ideology in psychoanalytic institutions
Paulo Soroka
On psychoanalytic writing
João Baptista N. F. França
The third in psychoanalytic thought
Daniel Widlöcher
The fourth basic assumption
Paulo Cesar Sandler, São Paulo
The origins of this study are
in some questions commonly found in the psychoanalytic
clinic, from where the experiences that form its empiric
basis were abstracted. It refers to the realm of proper
psychoanalysis as well as to psychoanalysis applied
to groups. It tries to deal psychoanalytically deal
with that which has been regarded as "crises"
in the psychoanalytic movement. It may interest to
colleagues that dedicate themselves to the institutional
activity, and it refers to analysts' intragroup relationship
as well as to analytic formation. It starts from the
observation that social groups live on shared hallucination;
they favour wars against the reality in the extent
they provide a social locus to shelter and stimulate
a psychotic trait, namely, the phantasy of superiority
linked to primary narcissism (Freud), primary envy
(Klein) and freezing in the paranoid-schizoid position.
This phantasy enhances contempt to truth and life.
The study displays the material, methods, hypotheses,
furnishes illustrations that have originated the hypothesis
and will discuss it. The description of the empirical
basis includes, beyond the work in the consulting
room, attempts to apply psychoanalysis in the community.
The observation extended itself through a twenty-five
years span of time. The hypothesis emerged as a selected
fact that gave coherence to facts that remained dispersed
during fifteen years.
I think that I observed the existence of a fourth
"basic assumption" as an obstacle to the
formation of a working group, in addition to the three
basic assumptions previously described by Bion. The
fourth "basic assumption" may be called,
"Hallucinosis of Exclusion/Appertaining".
It would be a proneness of human beings in when grouped
to hallucinate that they belong to the group or are
excluded from the group. Its psychic origin seems
to have two bearings: for one hand, a more primitive
one, linked to processes of splitting and another
which is more mature, based in the oedipal phantasies
of exclusion.
The autistic states and the theory of transformations.
The autistic transformations: a proposition
Celia Fix Korbivcher, São Paulo
This work integrates two areas
of thinking: one in which the author develops considerations
regarding observation methods of mental phenomena
in psychoanalysis, according to Bion's Theory of Transformations;
the other in which she is concerned about the investigation
of primitive mental states - proto-mental states -
more specifically, the autistic states of neurotic
patients, described by Frances Tustin.
Some ideas on the "philosophical" posture
underlying the Theory of Transformations are elaborated,
specially emphasizing the idea that the same phenomenon
in psychoanalysis can be considered from different
vertices, as long as it is situated within the theoretical
reference to which it belongs. The author cogitates
over the idea that this way of phenomena observation
is a part of a wider context of general human knowledge,
in which uncertainty and relativity of concepts are
the main ingredients.
By adopting the Theory of Transformations as a vertex
of phenomena observation that pervades the analytical
meeting, the author questions whether it is possible
to include other types of transformations of emotional
experiences in this theory, which evidences particular
phenomena with specific qualities, distinct from those
emphasized by Bion.
She hypothesizes that autistic phenomena present in
neurotic patients, which characterizes autistic states,
may be considered and detached, making up a particular
kind of Transformation of emotional experience with
which the analyst is often faced with in his/her daily
practice. She proposes the term Transformation in
Autism in order to name it.
Institutional romance
Carlos Ferreira Lopes Pires Leal, Nova
Friburgo
In this paper the author points
out that in the past century of psychoanalytic history
there is only one thing which more frequently rivals
with crisis experienced by its institutions: the non
application of psychoanalysis itself in order to understand
and work through them. After expounding on the establishment
of institution as an object to psychoanalysis, he
proposes the concept of institutional romance in order
to broaden the comprehension of phenomena engendered
by groupal-institutional relationships. The author
suggest that nowadays a pioneering stance would imply
recovering authorial responsibility in expanding psychoanalysis,
which would depend on understanding and transforming
psychoanalytical institutions.
Directing the scene: the analytical pair on
the stage of emotions
Gina Khafif Levinzon, São Paulo
The psychoanalytical method is
characterized by the search for approach to what is
singular in psyche. Its main foundations are the establishment
of a setting, the understanding of transference and
countertransference, the use of interpretation and
the discovery of what is not yet formulated.
This work examines these points in light of a clinical
case in which the analyst is invited to participate
actively in the plot created by the patient, and where
the roles such as author, director, spectator, patient
and analyst are interwoven.
The session takes place as if it was in a theatre
and the setting delimits the stage where transformations
occur. In the transference, imaginary characters are
experienced by both patient and analyst, as a result
of the third analytic, the space of intersection between
the patient and the analyst. The interpretative activity
focus on the search for an appropriate channel of
communication, using to this purpose the characters
created by the patient.
In this process of representation and self discovery
through the analytical process, conditions are established
for the encounter of the muse, source of the creative
inspiration, shared by the pair.
Ars Longa Vita Brevis
Ester Hadassa Sandler e Ligia Todescan
Lessa Mattos, São Paulo
In this paper the authors, out
of reading the Trilogy A Memoir of Future, bring some
reflections on the nature of the psychoanalytical
work, on the fundamentals of its practice and on the
conceptions of that which could be considered as "success"
or "failure" in psychoanalysis. Two levels
are proposed for scrutiny; one of them is called the
level of "many psychoanalysis", that of
the analyst's everyday work, practising his or her
profession, with the difficulties and frustrations
inherent to the work with patients who are called
"difficult"; the other level, is the "Psycho-Analysis"
one, where the repercussions of the anxieties aroused
in clinical work add to issues particular to the establishment
of Psycho-Analysis as a scientific discipline, whose
object of scrutiny is wide as Life itself, the very
human condition. May a science keep faithful to itself
and, at the same time, to develop? What are the hindrances
that interpolate between the everyday work and the
maintenance of the psychoanalytical method and vertex?
Adolescents without limits or "limit-functioning"
faced with an exigency soliciting the "dismissal
of the subject"?
Mônica Guimarães Teixeira
do Amaral, São Paulo
The present reflection intends
to deal with the regressive and authoritarian dimensions
of the contemporary world, seeking to establish a
tense dialogue - guarding the speciality of the speeches
of each author - in between the ideas of the German
Philosopher, Theodor W. Adorno, about the regressive
character of the Occidental Reason and the ideas of
the Psychoanalysts, such as Fabio Herrmann, who proposes
a critical reading of the authoritarian process which
has invaded the proper notion of the quotidian nowadays.
Conceiving Psychoanalysis, hence, not only as a clinical
method, but as a critical method of interpretation
of culture and supporting itself in the experience
of psychoanalytical treatment of adolescents considered
"without limits", the author seeks to re-think
on the idea of "acting-out" under the optic
of the "principal of the assault", in accordance
to Fabio Herrmann's conception (1982), purposely of
the real authoritarian, besides looking to articulate
it with the conception of some French psychoanalysts
regarding the limit-functioning, in which André
Green's reflections detach themselves (1999). The
approach of limits and possibilities in the psychoanalytical
technique is rooted in a radicalization of the psychoanalytical
method, to which was urging to contemplate the social-political
dimension of the phenomenon of the unconscious during
the contemporary times.
Sexuality and creativity: some considerations,
with emphasis on masculinity
José Nepomuceno, Brasília
The author presents some considerations
about sexuality and creativity, emphasizing the link
of those situations with identification and desire.
It is also underlined the vicissitudes of male sexuality,
especially the homosexual issue.
The vein that permeates the exposition is what may
be considered the cardinal aspect of the Freudian
legacy, i.e. the fact that we are desiring beings,
result of the impossibility of the human suckling
to survive without the care of another human being.
Thus, in general terms, three main points are raised.
First, it is presented and criticized a certain Freudian
view that considers the male sex as original and complete.
Second, comments are made on the link between sexuality
and subjective identification being also stressed
that homosexuality can jeopardize that process through
a fantasy of completeness, which is fundamental in
this sexual behaviour. Third, the author makes considerations
on sexuality and creativity suggesting that the constitution
of masculinity is a sign of a peculiar creative act
if compared to that involved in femininity.
Finally, it is proposed that homosexuality can be
an expression of maturity when it is possible to bar
the no-differentiation condition insinuated by identical
bodies. So, it is remarked that alterity can be established,
which is, apart from sexual questions, a basic requisite
for being in a healthy e vital way in the world.
Beyond transference: second thoughts concerning
the capacity to hallucinate
Claudio Castelo Filho, São Paulo
Clinical experience has shown
limitations in the performance of the psychoanalytical
work that is concerned only with transference. Further
development was made necessary and it came through
Bion's Transformations Theory. In transference situations
(renamed transformations in rigid motion) the analyst
interprets reactions to stimulations that can be observed
through the sense organs and that are common sense
to him and to the patient. In projective transformations
and in transformations in hallucinosis the stimulations
to which the patient reacts to are not observable
by the analyst. His main endeavor would be to find
out to what stimulations the patient is reacting to.
Their perception cannot be made by the sense organs.
It has to consider what they perceive in order to
intuit and "see" what they can't. To reach
this aim the analyst should use his capacity to hallucinate
(in dreams and in dream-thoughts). Doing this, he
would get in contact with his patient's psychic reality.
Regulation of memory and desire is a must for such
a task. The difference in the use of the capacity
to hallucinate between the analyst and the patient
would be that the first employs it to get in contact
with psychic truth and the former, to evade from it.
A clinical case and Shakespeare's Hamlet are used
to support the ideas exposed in the article.
The said and the unsaid - Secret structures
and ideology in psychoanalytic institutions
Paulo Soroka, Porto Alegre
Starting from the structure of
the Secret Committee, in the beginning of the history
of psychoanalysis, the author studies the dynamic
functioning of psychoanalytic institutions, which
are confronted with some characteristics of Secret
Societies. On this study, the ideology's perversion
is understood as a social defense sustained in order
to maintain the group cohesion, endangering its components'
autonomy and the principles of subjectivity that should
guide psychoanalysis itself. Some conflictive aspects
of psychoanalytic identity and the idealization mechanisms
associated are detached, as well as the colour they
imprint to ideology, in the ambit of institutional
life.
On psychoanalytic writing
João Baptista N. F. França,
São Paulo
In this paper, three aspects
of psychoanalytic writing are considered.
First, it is suggested that a mythical level is predominant
in psychoanalytic theory and practice. This happens
due to the strength and peculiarities of Freud' personality
and to the Institution created by him in order to
protect and to expand psychoanalysis.
A hypothesis is presented in which the oral character
of psychoanalytic transmission is centralized in the
experience of the couch.
Secondly, the scientific aspect of psychoanalysis
is discussed as well the importance of the written
production is emphasized in order to grant respectability
of our work.
Thirdly, the publications of Brazilian psychoanalysts
are analyzed and their peculiarities and shortcomings
are observed. The author presents then some conclusions
obtained from several meetings of the Editorial Board
of our Journal, the Revista Brasileira de Psicanálise,
held in order to discuss the subject.
The author and his team expect this paper to bring
some light into the improvement of psychoanalytic
writing in Brazil and some possible ways of reaching
this objective are suggested.
The third in psychoanalytic thought
Daniel Widlöcher, Paris
Freud, during his whole life,
showed a strong interest for occultism, more precisely
for telepathy or thought transfer (Denkenübertragung).
This interest occupied a large part of his relationships
with Ferenczi between 1909 and 1912 and gave matter
for three important texts between 1921 and 1933.
How can this interest be compatible with Freud's concern
to protect his method against the accusation of suggestion
and to maintain its objectivity? The role of empathy,
as a thought transference, gives us a solution to
this question and constitutes the ethic of psychoanalysis,
through the general principle of supervision, as a
process of transmission of an intersubjective experience
to a third person.
Rua Sergipe,
475 - 8º s/ 807 - São Paulo - SP - Brazil
Phone: (11) 3661-8709 Fax: (11) 3661-9473
E-mail: correio@rbp.org.br